| 2s | The Battle of Bywater | — | rare | $5.63 | |
| 4s | Boromir, Warden of the Tower | — | rare | $10.96 | |
| 5s | Dawn of a New Age | — | mythic | $8.63 | |
| 15s | Flowering of the White Tree | — | rare | $12.42 | |
| 17s | Forge Anew | — | rare | $6.62 | |
| 18s | Frodo, Sauron's Bane | — | rare | $2.54 | |
| 19s | Gandalf the White | — | mythic | $18.15 | |
| 36s | War of the Last Alliance | — | rare | $5.67 | |
| 44s | Borne Upon a Wind | — | rare | $12.69 | |
| 52s | Goldberry, River-Daughter | — | rare | $8.44 | |
| 61s | Lost Isle Calling | — | rare | $1.41 | |
| 65s | Press the Enemy | — | rare | $2.65 | |
| 66s | Rangers of Ithilien | — | rare | $1.04 | |
| 69s | Scroll of Isildur | — | rare | $2.65 | |
| 72s | Storm of Saruman | — | mythic | $10.05 | |
| 75s | The Watcher in the Water | — | mythic | $5.66 | |
| 79s | Call of the Ring | — | rare | $7.24 | |
| 91s | Isildur's Fateful Strike | — | rare | $1.86 | |
| 93s | Lobelia Sackville-Baggins | — | rare | $1.16 | |
| 102s | One Ring to Rule Them All | — | rare | $6.48 | |
| 103s | Orcish Bowmasters | — | rare | $71.35 | |
| 106s | Sauron, the Necromancer | — | rare | $10.10 | |
| 107s | Shadow of the Enemy | — | mythic | $4.46 | |
| 114s | Witch-king of Angmar | — | mythic | $11.48 | |
| 119s | Display of Power | — | rare | $1.59 | |
| 120s | Éomer, Marshal of Rohan | — | rare | $2.89 | |
| 124s | Fall of Cair Andros | — | rare | $1.78 | |
| 132s | Glóin, Dwarf Emissary | — | rare | $3.75 | |
| 136s | Hew the Entwood | — | mythic | $3.56 | |
| 138s | Moria Marauder | — | rare | $3.21 | |
| 149s | Spiteful Banditry | — | mythic | $11.93 | |
| 151s | There and Back Again | — | rare | $13.97 | |
| 158s | Delighted Halfling | — | rare | $37.07 | |
| 160s | Elven Chorus | — | rare | $6.31 | |
| 165s | Fall of Gil-galad | — | rare | $3.33 | |
| 166s | Fangorn, Tree Shepherd | — | rare | $2.74 | |
| 172s | Last March of the Ents | — | mythic | $38.39 | |
| 173s | Legolas, Master Archer | — | rare | $3.31 | |
| 184s | Radagast the Brown | — | mythic | $11.06 | |
| 186s | The Ring Goes South | — | rare | $2.35 | |
| 191s | Aragorn, Company Leader | — | rare | $2.72 | |
| 192s | Aragorn, the Uniter | — | mythic | $14.85 | |
| 193s | Arwen, Mortal Queen | — | mythic | $13.05 | |
| 195s | The Balrog, Durin's Bane | — | rare | $4.63 | |
| 199s | Doors of Durin | — | rare | $3.74 | |
| 200s | Elrond, Master of Healing | — | rare | $1.71 | |
| 201s | Éowyn, Fearless Knight | — | rare | $6.15 | |
| 202s | Faramir, Prince of Ithilien | — | rare | $2.67 | |
| 203s | Flame of Anor | — | rare | $6.87 | |
| 206s | Galadriel of Lothlórien | — | rare | $2.90 | |
| 207s | Gandalf the Grey | — | rare | $14.26 | |
| 209s | Gimli, Mournful Avenger | — | rare | $1.35 | |
| 211s | King of the Oathbreakers | — | rare | $3.19 | |
| 213s | Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | — | rare | $25.07 | |
| 215s | Merry, Esquire of Rohan | — | rare | $8.62 | |
| 218s | Pippin, Guard of the Citadel | — | rare | $4.15 | |
| 222s | Samwise Gamgee | — | rare | $8.19 | |
| 223s | Saruman of Many Colors | — | mythic | $6.07 | |
| 224s | Sauron, the Dark Lord | — | mythic | $57.41 | |
| 225s | Sauron's Ransom | — | rare | $2.42 | |
| 228s | Shagrat, Loot Bearer | — | rare | $1.47 | |
| 229s | Sharkey, Tyrant of the Shire | — | rare | $0.90 | |
| 230s | Shelob, Child of Ungoliant | — | rare | $9.81 | |
| 231s | Sméagol, Helpful Guide | — | rare | $2.44 | |
| 234s | Tom Bombadil | — | mythic | $49.56 | |
| 236s | Andúril, Flame of the West | — | mythic | $10.09 | |
| 239s | Glamdring | — | mythic | $7.72 | |
| 240s | Horn of Gondor | — | rare | $5.06 | |
| 241s | Horn of the Mark | — | rare | $2.57 | |
| 245s | Mithril Coat | — | rare | $31.68 | |
| 246s | The One Ring | — | mythic | $250.65 | |
| 247s | Palantír of Orthanc | — | mythic | $39.73 | |
| 248s | Phial of Galadriel | — | rare | $3.39 | |
| 250s | Sting, the Glinting Dagger | — | rare | $9.09 | |
| 253s | Barad-dûr | — | rare | $4.25 | |
| 256s | Minas Tirith | — | rare | $9.11 | |
| 257s | Mines of Moria | — | rare | $2.77 | |
| 258s | Mount Doom | — | mythic | $34.01 | |
| 259s | Rivendell | — | rare | $3.08 | |
| 260s | The Shire | — | rare | $3.93 | |
| 399s | Lobelia Sackville-Baggins | borderless | rare | $2.06 | |
| 400s | Wizard's Rockets | borderless | common | $1.01 | |
| 401s | Gandalf, Friend of the Shire | borderless | uncommon | $2.44 | |
| 402s | Delighted Halfling | borderless | rare | $30.92 | |
| 403s | Bilbo, Retired Burglar | borderless | uncommon | $0.48 | |
| 404s | Frodo Baggins | borderless | uncommon | $0.43 | |